31 N Pleasant St, Amherst, MA 01002, USA
Always friendly staff who obviously enjoy their work. The pizza is always great and the wide selection means everyone gets to order exactly what they want to eat. My favorite is the eggplant with roasted red pepper. Awesome!
- Steve Krause, 2/17/2020
Visiting Amherst and I heard this place had great pizza. Even a customer inside the store told me it’s the “best in town” so I just knew it was going to be good. Ordered a customized pizza before a rush and the wait seemed longer than expected. Once I started noticing others who came in after me get their pizza I spoke up and asked how much longer my wait was going to be and they told me 2 minutes. About another 10 minutes go by and the employee tries to quietly slide me a free pie card stating they messed up on my order. After over a 30 minute wait for a pizza I had already paid for! I was so frustrated and upset I just asked for a refund. Due to the poor customer service I didn’t even want the free pie or the pizza that had what I didn’t eat on it. That was the whole point of me paying extra to customize my pizza because I only eat certain things! Definitely will not be coming back during my stay here.
- Misha Nelson, 9/9/2019